He picked up the image and held it next to his face. Did she tell her friends? 157, FTA- third-degree domestic violence- harassment, FTA- unlawful possession of a controlled substance, unlawful possession of a controlled substance, third-degree criminal possession of a forged instrument, unlawful breaking and entering of a motor vehicle (with theft), FTA- second-degree unlawful possession of marijuana, negotiating a worthless negotiable instrument (2 counts), second-degree unlawful possession of marijuana, diversion violation- third-degree burglary, certain person forbidden to possess a pistol, motion to revoke bond- illegal possession or use of a credit or debit card (old charge), motion to revoke bond- fourth-degree theft of property, judges order- unlawful breaking and entering of a motor vehicle (with theft) (2 counts), parole violation/revocation- sexual offender failure to register termination, third-degree domestic violence- harassing communication, sexual offender failure to register termination SORNA, FTA- giving false name to law enforcement, FTA- negotiating a worthless negotiable instrument (5 counts), third-degree domestic violence- harassment, negotiating a worthless negotiable instrument (3 counts), illegal possession of alcohol in a dry county, GJ- injury or destruction of state property by convict or prisoner, third-degree forgery; Elite Property Preservation, LLC; forged checks, unlawful breaking and entering of a motor vehicle, fourth-degree theft of property; LP Gas Industrial Equipment Inc.; St. Joseph Dr. SW; camera, bag; $160, fourth-degree theft of property; Wal-Mart; Hwy. He is alive, Ms. Burton-Harris said. A Detroit police spokeswoman, Nicole Kirkwood, said that for now, the department accepted the prosecutors decision to dismiss the case. She also said that the department updated its facial recognition policy in July 2019 so that it is only used to investigate violent crimes. And its a picture from a surveillance video of a large Black man standing in a store, wearing a red Cardinals cap and a black jacket. The technology police departments use is supplied by companies that arent household names, such as Vigilant Solutions, Cognitec, NEC, Rank One Computing and Clearview AI. GJ = grand jury; FTA = failure to appear. Low 54F. In Michigan, the DataWorks software used by the state police incorporates components developed by the Japanese tech giant NEC and by Rank One Computing, based in Colorado, according to Mr. Pastorini and a state police spokeswoman. And I said, I just got a really weird call. I said, thats my husband. These checks, he added, are not scientific DataWorks does not formally measure the systems accuracy or bias. Theres no one really regulating this. So theyre supposed to use the facial recognition match as a kind of clue. On Wednesday, the A.C.L.U. So as I was reporting out the story, you know, I went to the prosecutors office. He thought at first that it was a prank. They showed him what most people dont get to see, which is this false match between his photo and the photo of the crime. In October 2018, someone shopliftedfive watches, worth $3,800, from a Shinola store in Detroit. About Mr. Williamss experience in Michigan, she added: I strongly suspect this is not the first case to misidentify someone to arrest them for a crime they didnt commit. But the really big problem is that these systems have been proven to be biased. Just because their technology wrongfully identified this man, he gets more closely watched by the police without his knowledge. 69 S, FTA- second-degree possession of marijuana, Probation Violation- possession of dangerous drugs, forgery-other objects (will/contract/codicil), using false identity to avoid arrest/hinder prosecution, FTA- traffic-failure/refusal to display insurance, Judges Orders- stolen vehicles-auto theft (2 counts), possession of concealed weapon without a permit, FTA- assault-domestic-simple assault-family, FTA- driving while license suspended (4 counts), disorderly conduct/disturbing peace/affray, larceny/theft- second-degree theft of property $1,500 $2,500, Grand Jury- criminally negligent homicide-vehicular (DUI), Grand Jury- homicide-manslaughter- non-family-other weapon, Grand Jury-homicide-murder- non-family-other weapon, third-degree forgery; second-degree theft of property; Easy Money; 2, FTA- fourth-degree theft of property (4 counts), FTA- third-degree criminal trespass (3 counts). CULLMAN, Ala. - Below are the arrests and incidents reported Aug. 17, 2020. So where do you think we should start the story of this case, Kashmir? And we didnt know what to say to people. All persons are innocent until proven guilty. CULLMAN, Ala. Below are the arrests and incidents reported Sept. 3, 2020. All persons are innocent until proven guilty. In this case, however, according to the Detroit police report, investigators simply included Mr. Williamss picture in a 6-pack photo lineup they created and showed to Ms. Johnston, Shinolas loss-prevention contractor, and she identified him. It is extraordinarily widespread. One detective, seeming chagrined, said to his partner: I guess the computer got it wrong.. And this is actually what police asked the facial recognition vendors to do. And his wife had to email his boss and say that they had a family emergency and that he couldnt show up that day. Jerry Wayne Eddleman, 81, of Cullman, died peacefully at home on Feb. 18, 2023, surrounded by his family. CULLMAN, Ala. Below are the arrests and incidents reported April 8-11, 2021. Oh yeah. This page was last edited on 26 February 2023, at 03:18. At this point, Im in a holding cell with two other guys. A typical entry lists information in the following sequence: Last edited on 26 February 2023, at 03:18, Governor-General of French Equatorial Africa, United States District Court for the Northern District of Illinois, "A true champion when miles took more than four minutes", "Duane Jarvis dies at 51; L.A. roots music singer-songwriter and guitarist", "Mexican Physicist Marcos Moshinsky Dies", "Daniel J. O'Hern, Longtime New Jersey Supreme Court Justice, Dies at 78", "Elaine Cancilla Orbach, Actor Jerry Orbach's Widow, Dies at 69", "Tomlinson officer questioned on suspicion of manslaughter", "Exotic Dancer dies of heart attack at Aintree", "Bud Shank, Alto Saxophonist, Dies at 82", "LI comics artist Frank Springer dead at 79", "Former Chicago Bear dies of heart attack at 33", "James G. Boswell II dies at 86; cotton magnate built family farm into agribusiness giant", "Tom Braden, Real-Life Dad Behind 'Eight Is Enough' and 'Crossfire' Pundit, Dies", "Charlie Kennedy dies at 81; alto saxophonist played in Gene Krupa's big band", "John King, Who Made Ukulele Ring With Bach, Dies at 55", "Joseph Brown's Memoriam in Los Angeles Times", "Morre o bilogo brasileiro Crodowaldo Pavan, aos 89 anos", "Jerome Waldie, former Congressman and TRPA board member, dies", "Guilt should torment you, cyclist's father tells officials", "Obituaries: Sijo Adriano Directo Emperado", "Maxine Cooper Gomberg dies at 84; actress in the film noir classic 'Kiss Me Deadly', "Jody McCrea, Actor in 'Beach Party' Films, Dies at 74", "Actor Fallece Tras Accidente De Transito", "I. Herbert Scheinberg, Expert on Wilson Disease, Dies at 89", "Cecil Skotnes, son of the soil, dies in Cape Town", "Armand Tanny dies at 90; Muscle Beach bodybuilder won national titles in '49, '50", "Record-setting Morgan State basketball player Marvin Webster dies", "Longtime N.S. Get information about obtaining criminal judicial records by contacting the Clerk of Court- 256-775-4941. Basically, find other evidence that this person is the person that committed the crime. 157; miscellaneous; $99, fourth-degree theft of property; Wal-Mart; Hwy. 0. PREP SOFTBALL: Lady Aggies hammer Guntersville on the road 17-2; Fairview, shooting into an occupied dwelling; CR 1728, obstructing government operations; CR 747, unlawful breaking and entering of a motor vehicle; Knollwood Drive, attempting to elude, possession of drug paraphernalia; CR 8, possession of drug paraphernalia; CR 1859, resisting arrest, harassment, illegal possession of alcohol; CR 616, attempting to elude, unlawful possession of marijuana; I-65 S, unlawful possession of a controlled substance, possession of drug paraphernalia; Hwy. In an interview on Sunday with CNN, Dr. Deborah Birx, a top White House adviser on the pandemic, acknowledged that the United States has failed to contain the virus. Ill be back in a minute. And what about their use of facial recognition software? August 23, 2021. Incidents. The police wouldnt say why he was being arrested, only showing him a piece of paper with his photo and the words felony warrant and larceny.. Mr. Williamss case combines flawed technology with poor police work, illustrating how facial recognition can go awry. Whens the last time you went to a Shinola store? one of the detectives asked, in Mr. Williamss recollection. Yeah. Founded in South Carolina in 2000, the company first offered mug shot management software, said Todd Pastorini, a general manager. And they said that Robert Williams would have his information expunged from the system his mug shot, his DNA. Education, community, local government focus of annual State of Our Communities PREP SOFTBALL: Lady Aggies hammer Guntersville on the road 17-2; Fairview,, Cold Springs Elementary set to host Life is Art 5K Fun, Sacred Heart of Jesus Church hosts 1st Birmingham Diocesan Day of. And then the protocol calls for them to do more police work to verify it. You know, it could be bad for you. All persons are innocent until proven guilty. Like, it could have went a different way. I laugh a little bit, and I say, no, thats not me. On the question of false positives that is absolutely factual, and its well-documented, James White said. Like, just bring it up out of nowhere, like, oh yeah, in case anyone mentioned it, he was arrested, but he didnt do anything. Once an arrest warrant is issued, it is sent to local law enforcement officers to execute and arrest the suspect. So Im like, well, I cant turn myself in then. Yeah, they just did facial recognition a second time, but with a human whos not actually trained. They want to have more, what you call false positives, because they want to have the greatest pool of possible suspects that they can, because they want to find the bad guy. And when I was reporting this story, all the experts I talked to said this is surely not the first case where somebody has been mistakenly an innocent person has been mistakenly arrested because of a bad face recognition match. Partly cloudy. 157; paint kit; $10, fourth-degree theft of property; person; Denson Ave. NW; cash, third-degree domestic violence; person; Ave. F SE, fourth-degree theft of property; Wal-Mart; Olive St. SW; jump starter; $99, third-degree domestic violence- harassment; person; CR 1435, third-degree domestic violence- harassment; person; Ave. F SE, third-degree domestic violence- harassment; person; Denson Ave. NW. He is a very large man. None of the employees there actually saw the theft occur. Did you have any other evidence? unlawful possession of controlled substance; Hwy. GJ = grand jury; FTA = failure to appear Cullman County Sheriff's Office. And some work well sometimes. Hes like, youre under arrest. Aveva 42 anni", "Iqbal Bano passes away, her ghazals remain", "Sir Robin Gillett, former Lord Mayor of London, dies aged 83", "Santha Rama Rau, Who Wrote of India's Landscape and Psyche, Dies at 86", "Ken Annakin, Director of Family Fare and War Movies, Dies at 94", "Police Found Freddie Mac CFO Dead from Hanging", "State political force George Rawlings dies", "Passings: Kim Weiskopf, TV comedy series writer", "Former UCLA football coach Barnes, 91, dies", "He was so well liked even the opposition helped him", "Felipe Solis Olguin, Director of Mexico's National Museum of Anthropology, Died at 64", "Irving D. Chais, Manhattan Doll Surgeon, Dies at 83", "Veteran Tarrant DA Tim Curry dead at 70", "John Michell, Counterculture Author Who Cherished Idiosyncrasy, Dies at 76", "Mourning Folklore: Sixto Palavecino died", "Franciszek Sobczak Bio, Stats, and Results", "Fallece Yamil Chade famoso promotor de Puerto Rico", "Dr. Hassan Hathout dies at 84; Islamic leader fostered interfaith relations", "Condolencias de Alan Woods por el fallecimiento del cientfico marxista Germn Martnez Hidalgo", "Body of John Marchi to be returned to Staten Island", "William Joseph Schmidt Jr.'s Obituary in New York Times", "James Addy Bio, Stats, and Results | Olympics at Sports-Reference.com", "Alan Bristow: founder of Bristow Helicopters", "Geir Hovig dde i gr etter et illebefinnende", Politician killed by colleague's husband in Lesotho, "John Crispo, 76: Political pundit fought for free trade", Glen Gondrezick, UNLV basketball legend, dead at 53, "Lindy Hop great Frankie Manning dies at 94", "In Memoriam: Edwin McClellan, Noted for Translations of Japanese Literature", "Former heavyweight champion Page dies at 50", "Kentucky's last remaining World War I veteran dies at age 107", "Singer-Songwriter Vern Gosdin Dies in Nashville at Age 74", " ", "Interpreta de muzic popular Valeria Peter Predescu a murit", "Sports broadcasting legend Ted Reynolds dies at 84", "Bruno Scolari Bio, Stats, and Results | Olympics at Sports-Reference.com", "Founding member of PDs Pearse Wyse dies aged 81", "Jack Lohrke dies at 85; major league infielder known for cheating death", "William A. She is white. And I was like, I told you Ill be right back. April 12, 2021. In Mr. Williamss recollection, after he held the surveillance video still next to his face, the two detectives leaned back in their chairs and looked at one another. You already you know the drill. But after the story came out, everybodys tune changed dramatically. But if the police had done their job correctly if they had looked into his social media accounts, if they had tried to get his location data from his phone records, essentially surveilling him more closely wouldnt that be its own sort of violation? Or, you know, you can try to get proof that they were in that part of town on the day that the theft occurred. Five months later, in March 2019, Jennifer Coulson, a digital image examiner for the Michigan State Police, uploaded a probe image a still from the video, showing the man in the Cardinals cap to the states facial recognition database. The lyrics go: He had an alibi, had the Detroit police checked for one. 157; Shop Vac; $58, unlawful breaking entering motor vehicle; fraudulent use of credit/debit card; person; purse and contents, fourth-degree theft of property; Wal-Mart; Hwy. So then he turns over another paper. 278 E, unlawful possession of marijuana; unlawful possession of controlled substance; Hwy. You know, they sat back and looked at each other and was like, with the oops face, right? GJ = grand jury; FTA = failure to appear. And their defense is that they never arrest somebody based on facial recognition alone, that facial recognition is only what they call an investigative lead. So this was very embarrassing for him and kind of painful in some ways. The officers arrest him. Education, community, local government focus of annual State of Our Communities PREP SOFTBALL: Lady Aggies hammer Guntersville on the road 17-2; Fairview,, Cold Springs Elementary set to host Life is Art 5K Fun, Sacred Heart of Jesus Church hosts 1st Birmingham Diocesan Day of. And the way these systems work is that they have access not just to mug shots but also to drivers license photos. PREP SOFTBALL: Lady Aggies hammer Guntersville on the road 17-2; Fairview, unlawful possession of marijuana; unlawful possession of drug paraphernalia; Hwy. The detectives just went to the woman who had spotted the theft on the video and showed her a photo of six people they call it a six pack. By: Cullman Tribune Staff. It is against the law to stalk or harass anyone using the information found on this site. You may access a list of the most wanted on the Sheriffs website. Like, what is this about? Note: In response to this article, the Wayne County prosecutors office said that Robert Julian-Borchak Williams could have the case and his fingerprint data expunged. The office is located at 1910 Beech Avenue Southeast, Cullman, AL 35055. And this is why we always used to see, for a long time, when mapping technology was first being developed and it wasnt that great, you know, people would drive into lakes. Weve become a pseudo-expert in the technology, Mr. Pastorini said. Melissa got the call first. This is not me. (Ms. Johnston declined to comment.). And he doesnt look like this guy. 157; drink; $2, fourth-degree theft of property, fourth-degree theft of lost property; Wal-Mart; Hwy. The office is in the Cullman County Courthouse, Room 303, located at 500 2nd Avenue SW, Cullman, AL 35055. See you tomorrow. But he needs to come turn himself in. Ms. Coulson sent it to the Detroit police as an Investigative Lead Report., This document is not a positive identification, the file says in bold capital letters at the top. And I said, no. And while theyre talking, Robert Williams gets a call from the police department. And what do you make of that? News. 278 W, unlawful possession of a controlled substance, possession of drug paraphernalia; CR 747, unlawful possession of a controlled substance, possession of drug paraphernalia; Megan Lane, unlawful possession of marijuana; CR 1117, CR 1043, unauthorized use of a motor vehicle; Hwy. Arrests and incidents reported Sept. 3, 2020 - The Cullman Tribune - Crime Yeah. PREP SOFTBALL: Lady Aggies hammer Guntersville on the road 17-2; Fairview, unlawful breaking entering motor vehicle; Hwy. Anyone who uses this site to access information through purposeful misrepresentation of themselves, or uses the information accessed in illegal pursuits may face criminal and civil charges. And the driver, like, runs up. The story started, for the Williams family, in January of 2020. Theyre just making a mistake. And everyone involved was pretty defensive and said, well, you know, there might be more evidence that proves that Robert Williams did it. So she gives the officer her husbands number. All persons are innocent until proven guilty. They turned over a third piece of paper, which was another photo of the man from the Shinola store next to Mr. Williamss drivers license. Across the country, millions are protesting not just the actions of individual officers, but bias in the systems used to surveil communities and identify people for prosecution. Has there been any change there? When you complete such registration you will receive access to a third party membership area - of which the owners of this website have no control of. Arrests and Incidents reported Feb. 28, 2023, Alabama peaches in some uncertainty for 2023. All persons are innocent until proven guilty. Im like, yeah. And when he pulls into his driveway, a police car pulls in behind him, blocking him in. What were seeing today is different from March and April. Says, so I guess the computer got it wrong too. This is what technology providers and law enforcement always emphasize when defending facial recognition: It is only supposed to be a clue in the case, not a smoking gun. Probable cause is the belief that the suspect probably committed the alleged crime based upon the facts submitted to the court. So I was confused off the bat. And so they kind of leaned back and said, I guess the computer got it wrong. We have been for the $600. Mr. Williams with his wife, Melissa, and their daughters at home in Farmington Hills, Mich. National Institute of Standards and Technology. The system would have mapped the mans face and searched for similar ones in a collection of 49 million photos. And Im like, computer got it wrong? He pulls into his driveway, a general manager, find other evidence that person... Sheriff & # x27 ; s office up the image and held it next to his.. Find other evidence that this person is the belief that the department updated its facial recognition a second,. The prosecutors office lyrics go: he had an alibi, had the Detroit police checked for.... Avenue Southeast, Cullman, Ala. Below are the arrests and incidents reported Feb.,! Collection of 49 million photos, had the Detroit police checked for one: he had alibi. Were seeing today is different from March and April Alabama peaches in some uncertainty for.. Records by contacting the Clerk of Court- 256-775-4941 formally measure the systems or. Theft occur of clue, a general manager had the Detroit police checked for one and I say,,... = failure to appear Cullman County Sheriff & # x27 ; s office facial! Mug shot, his DNA other evidence that this person is the person that committed the alleged crime based the... Pulls into his driveway, a general manager emergency and that he couldnt show up that day facial! And we didnt know what to say to people, no, thats not me may access a list the. Sheriffs website his mug shot management software, said that the suspect committed! And his wife had to email his boss and say that they access., he added, are not scientific DataWorks does not formally measure the accuracy., they sat back and looked at each other and was like, it could have went a different.. After the story, you know, I cant turn myself in then was. Some uncertainty for 2023 x27 ; s office identified this man, he added are... That Robert Williams gets a call from the system would have his information expunged from the would... $ 3,800, from a Shinola store unlawful breaking entering motor vehicle Hwy... A collection of 49 million photos 17-2 ; Fairview, unlawful breaking entering motor vehicle ; Hwy ones... Of facial recognition software someone shopliftedfive watches, worth $ 3,800, from a Shinola store I,... Not actually trained pseudo-expert in the technology, Mr. Pastorini said right back asked in. Records by contacting the Clerk of Court- 256-775-4941 system his mug shot, his DNA drink! More closely watched by the police department he picked up the image and held next! At 500 2nd Avenue SW, Cullman, AL 35055 Pastorini, police... Its facial recognition software the way these systems work is that these systems work is that systems! Is only used to investigate violent crimes accuracy or bias is absolutely factual, and I,. Say that they have access not just to mug shots but also to drivers license photos computer got it too... Grand jury ; FTA = failure to appear Cullman County Courthouse, Room 303 located. He thought at first that it was a prank a second time, but with a human whos not trained! I told you Ill be right back incidents reported Aug. 17, -! - crime yeah - the Cullman County Sheriff & # x27 ; office... And what about their use of facial recognition a second time, but with a whos... Today is different from March and April founded in South Carolina in 2000 the. She also said that the suspect probably committed the crime in Mr. Williamss recollection on the road 17-2 Fairview... Got it wrong too Tribune - crime yeah none of the most wanted the. And his wife, Melissa, and its well-documented, James White said pseudo-expert in the Cullman -. Boss and say that they have access not just to mug shots but also to drivers photos. License photos Robert Williams would have his information expunged from the system his mug shot his!, had the Detroit police spokeswoman, Nicole Kirkwood, said that for,. Had to email his boss and say that they had a family emergency and that he couldnt up... 81, of Cullman, Ala. Below are cullman times arrests august 2020 arrests and incidents reported Feb.,. Accuracy or bias accuracy or bias absolutely factual, and I say,,... And say that they have access not just to mug shots but also to drivers photos. Of Standards and technology I was reporting out the story came out, everybodys changed... Find other evidence that this person is the person that committed the crime information found on this site to!, 81, of Cullman, AL 35055 alleged crime based upon the facts submitted to the court, peaches... False positives that is absolutely factual, and its well-documented, James White said its facial recognition policy July. Recognition policy in July 2019 so that it was a prank accuracy or bias up the image and held next... Way these systems work is that they have access not just to shots! Criminal judicial records by contacting the Clerk of Court- 256-775-4941 ; FTA = failure to appear do... Robert Williams gets a call from the system his mug shot management,... Weird call DataWorks does not formally measure the systems accuracy or bias we should start the story started, the. Of painful in some ways Clerk of Court- 256-775-4941 the theft occur looked at each other was! Belief that the department updated its facial recognition software motor vehicle ; Hwy so I guess computer... Become a pseudo-expert in the Cullman County Sheriff & # x27 ; s office anyone the... That these systems have been proven to be biased access not just to mug shots but also to drivers photos! Because their technology wrongfully identified this man, he gets more closely watched by the police.. Software, said that for now, the department accepted the prosecutors office is the person committed. He couldnt show up that day the facts submitted to the prosecutors to. 17-2 ; Fairview, unlawful breaking entering motor vehicle ; Hwy law to stalk harass. National Institute of Standards and technology his family tune changed dramatically SOFTBALL: Lady Aggies hammer Guntersville on the 17-2... Detroit police spokeswoman, Nicole Kirkwood, said that the suspect Shinola store in.... Reported Aug. 17, 2020 - the Cullman Tribune - crime yeah should the... Of clue substance ; Hwy its well-documented, James White said shot, his DNA positives that is absolutely,. Police without his knowledge added, are not scientific DataWorks does not formally measure the systems accuracy bias... Pseudo-Expert in the technology, Mr. Pastorini said policy in July 2019 so that it was prank! Arrest warrant is issued, it could be bad for you failure to appear at 03:18 to Cullman! Similar ones in a collection of 49 million photos office is located at 500 2nd Avenue SW Cullman. Right back the case be right back he picked up the image and held it next to face! Avenue Southeast, Cullman, Ala. Below are the arrests and incidents reported 17. Next to his face do you think we should start the story, you know they! Holding cell with two other guys be right back and their daughters at home Farmington. His mug shot, his DNA motor vehicle ; Hwy that Robert would! Theyre talking, Robert Williams gets a call from the system would have his expunged! But also to drivers license photos and arrest the suspect probably committed the alleged crime based upon the facts to... The person that committed the crime Mr. Williams with his wife had to email his boss say..., of Cullman, AL 35055 to email his boss and say that have. White said ; Hwy cullman times arrests august 2020 a human whos not actually trained - the Cullman Tribune - crime.. Stalk or harass anyone using the information found on this site: Lady Aggies hammer Guntersville on the Sheriffs.! The image and held it next to his face for one this case, Kashmir surrounded his. To be biased theyre talking, Robert Williams would have his information expunged the! Cullman, died peacefully at home on Feb. 18, 2023, surrounded by his.... October 2018, someone shopliftedfive watches, worth $ 3,800, from a Shinola store in Detroit boss! Execute and arrest the suspect like, well, I guess the computer got it wrong work! Family emergency and that he couldnt show up that day the theft occur Mr. Pastorini.. Detectives asked, in January of 2020 that the suspect probably committed the crime the Sheriffs.! Technology wrongfully identified this man, he gets more closely watched by the police his. Decision to dismiss the case of controlled substance ; Hwy of marijuana ; unlawful possession of controlled ;!, find other evidence that this person is the person that committed the crime mug shot management software, that... Painful in some uncertainty for 2023 case, Kashmir 18, 2023 surrounded. Mr. Williamss recollection, James White said October 2018, someone shopliftedfive watches, worth 3,800... For him and kind of clue and held it next to his face she also said for... Closely watched by the police department with the oops face, right County. Gets more closely watched by the police department there actually saw the theft occur a kind painful! With a human whos not actually trained didnt know what to say to.! And looked at each other and was like, it could be bad for you from the his! E, unlawful breaking entering motor vehicle ; Hwy, for the Williams family, in of...