tomatoes, cheeses, and other goods on the corner of Arthur Avenue and 186th Street since 1915. for our newsletter. Kudos if you make it home without digging into it on the subway. By Ken Gabrielsen. Heres a look at more of the citys oldest bakeries still serving up great bites and history. Pietro Parrotta, Calabria Pork Store. 28 Lupfer Ave. Whitefish, Montana. The Clinton Hall Beer Garden is also a new neighbor, attracting those who want to try the latest craft beers. More than specialties, these were born out of need. Never again. No matter where you go, the food is just amazing. At the table, where white cloth adds a measure of panache to the warm, relaxed surrounds, chefs specials rule the night and day, though the regular menu is far from run of the mill, with classic and creative chicken, fish, and veal selections, handmade pastas, salads, and alluring antipasto platters. 2354 Arthur Avenue Open daily 7:00 am - 5:30 pm. The family-run Sicilian bakery has been operating since 1918 and has been churning out variety breads, biscotti, cookies and piped-to-order cannolis . Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh. But dont fill up, or youll miss crisp calamari, pillow-soft gnocchi, and tender lamb chops. An award winning menu, the finest imported Italian food products, specialty gifts, and more. Contact . The baby on the block (at just two decades young), this family-run, rustically upscale bistro-style hotspot charms with a marble-topped bar and white-clothed tables set against warm, red-brick walls. A family feel permeates the air, and inventive, elevated specials of grilled branzino or stuffed zucchini flowers enliven a menu of reliable lasagna, eggplant parm, and Sicilian meatballs that are dotted, in the traditional manner, with currants and pignoli nuts. From the moment the door swings closed behind you, your senses are catapulted into the kitchen of a kindly Italian woman who always wants to know if youre hungry because thats how it all began. Pass time waiting in the shop's ever-pre Later, Im in Tinos Deli, getting another sandwich (hoping for a properly sized one), and the guy says, You know this is the Bronx, and its the Yankees here, right? Ugh. P.O. It is located on Belmont Avenue, off the main drag, and is known for its old school Italian cuisine. With all the money they had on the line, the family which included the couples six sons worked day and night, cranking out egg noodles. Other original items include Linzer tarts ($3.50 each; minis, $20 per pound), other treats have been added over the years. Use left/right arrows to navigate the slideshow or swipe left/right if using a mobile device. The paradox is real: Many New Yorkers never heard of the place, while for others its home away from home although it is often a well-kept secret. Countless iterations, but some of the most common are: Hi! I havent seen you in forever!; What are you doing?! I was born in the same house that my grandfather built, and Ive been deeply rooted in the local community. A fanabala: Bakeries Bars & Lounges Beauty & Barbershops Cafes Clothing & Accessories Delicatessens Financial, Insurance, & Legal Services Fish Markets Food & Drink Specialty Stores Grocery & Convenience Stores Institutions Meat Markets Medical & Dental Services Miscellaneous Services Pastry Shops Pizzerias Restaurants Specialty Stores, website designed and maintained by Chris Hurst, LITTLE ITALY IN THE BRONX and associated logo are trademarks and copyrights of the Belmont Business Improvement District. Nearly every shop on Arthur Avenue is already some sort of institution, as one writer put it. Mar 13, 2014 - What's not to love?. But shes best known for her oatmeal marshmallow cookie ($3). Subscribe to Our Newsletter. Despite everything going on in the world, we are still here, every day, making the best bread possible. He opened a social club at this 11th Street spot, where he roasted espresso and served homemade candies. People were scared we were going to change the recipes, says the 56-year-old of when her uncle, Ralph Difonzo, purchased Rudys in the early 1980s. Open for biz in 1915 by Austrian Jewish immigrant brothers, expect imported Italian cheeses, EVOO, tomatoes, pasta, and specialty items galore. Robert Zerilli, a co-owner of Venieros, is quick to mention Frank Sinatra while discussing the bakerys history. Copyright 20042023 Yelp Inc. Yelp, , and related marks are registered trademarks of Yelp. The lush cream that squeezes out of every bite is refreshingly sweet, and goes well with a lick of that chocolate glaze that'll surely be coating your lips. Delicious latte is waiting for you at this cafe. Its a dense, greasy wonder thatll leave your fingers slicked (and one bite will justify its miniature square size). Since 1922, hot and oven-ready Italian dishes, stuffed breads, and house-made burrata to boot! Concentrated across a four-block radius, these are the best Arthur Ave-area pastry shops worth traveling crosstown, north of 72nd, and across the Harlem River for. Your call. The result is a fragrant, lightly candied carb bomb perfect for the worlds most filling breakfast, or the worlds most filling snack. Use left/right arrows to navigate the slideshow or swipe left/right if using a mobile device. In its first 58 years, that was all the family baked for the neighborhoods population of Italians. This website IS NOT FOR LOCAL DELIVERY on NY. MADONIA BROTHERS BAKERY - 395 Photos & 309 Reviews - 2348 Arthur Ave, Bronx, NY - Yelp Yelp Yelp for Business Write a Review Log In Sign Up Restaurants Home Services Auto Services More More Madonia Brothers Bakery 309 reviews Unclaimed $ Bakeries Edit Open 6:00 AM - 7:00 PM See hours See all 396 photos Write a review Add photo Share Save Dating back to the 1700's, one of the Belmont neighborhood's first businesses was a tobacco company started by French Huguenot Pierre Abraham Lorillard in 1760, and it's still in operation today. Come along for the ride! Please support us and other small businesses as we continue to feed our communities. For some, it may seem out of place that a market owned and operated by a Jewish family would have some of the most authentic Italian goods stateside, but youd be remiss in thinking that Teitel Brothers is any less deserving of the real estate than a business that ends in a vowel. 2396 Arthur Avenue Bronx, NY 10458 (718)294-8259 info@BronxLittleItaly.com. I started with A, This is a real old style Italian bakery that you look for when you are coming to, An old style Italian bakery/caf in the Belmont ", Yelp users havent asked any questions yet about. By 1946, h . Inside, mirrored walls run below a stained-glass ceiling and above diamond-pattern tiled floors. Were getting involved more with social media, says co-owner Linda Martella, 69 Zerillis sister. Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh. Edward Teitel, Teitel Brothers. Ask any New Yorker about Arthur Avenue in the Bronx and you get either puzzlement or a flood of loving sentiment about the real Little Italy of New York, the best place for bread, pasta, meat, pastries,espresso machines, the only place to buy Italian sausage, and more. The area has also served as an inspiration for movies like Marty, A Bronx Tale, The Godfather, and The Sopranos. Rumor has it that actor Joe Pesci began his career after being discovered by actor Robert DeNiro at a local neighborhood restaurant where Pesci worked as the matre d. Franz added that a number of celebrities are also known to dine in the area to escape the limelight of Manhattan and enjoy delicious authentic ethnic cuisine. In 1870, the tobacco manufacturing facilities moved to New Jersey and Catherine Lorillard Wolfe, Pierres great granddaughter, inherited the estate. A husband and wife shop for 4+ decades offering house-cooked Italian classics, heroes, brick-oven pizza, and imported goods. Focaccia, ciabatta, all you knead is right here!Almond biscotti of all kind (pistachio chocolate chip is . Definitely order the fresh pasta. Arthur Avenue Bakeries For great bread and delicious pastries, you can stop by Terranova Bakery, Addeo Bakery or Madonia Bakery . Generations of Italian families have given the area a special small-town character unique for an urban setting, at the same time establishing traditions that permeate the neighborhood like the sweet smell of sausage and peppers. 670 East 187th Street. "Fifth Avenue and Arthur Avenue are two different worlds, different people, different customers," says Parubi, who started working at the bakery at age 18 as an Albanian native with a limited . Thanks for contacting us. For a sit-down taste of authentic Italy and old-world warmth and hospitality, these are the dining destinations you shouldnt miss. We are located in the Arthur Avenue Section of the Bronx at: 691 East 187th Street Bronx, NY 10458 Our Store Hours: Monday - Saturday: 7:30am - 4:00pm Sunday: 730am - 2:30pm Give Us a Call: 718-367-6985 DINING. Related: Make Randazzos Seafood Recipes for the Feast of the Seven Fishes. Maroon 5 tunes and a space decorated with a suburban mother/teachers eye for mosaicked chandeliers greet visitors at this clean-cut spot. 2023 NYP Holdings, Inc. All Rights Reserved, Here's Dunkin' Donuts' latest frankenfood, Canadian teacher with size-Z prosthetic breasts placed on paid leave, 11-year-old reads aloud from 'pornographic' book he checked out from library at school board meeting, Mike McCarthy shreds ex-Cowboys coordinator after firing, 'Jeopardy!' 4 Generations of Baking, from Our Family to Yours. Today, Caputos Bake Shop continues producing its longtime specialty: bread. Some New York natives are quick to point out that Arthur Avenue should be acknowledged as the "real Little Italy;" the Italian immigrant history that began in 1950's is still strong today. Mailing Address. Come here for a drink after a long walk around Dick Idol Signature Gallery. While within the continental United States, Arthur Avenue feels like a different world. On July 1, 2018, the space will close for good. Case in point: Italian pastries. Established in 1912, the Egidio Pastry Shop is the oldest bakery in the neighborhood. Feel free to reach out at any time with any questions or comments. In 1915, they opened Teitel Brothers grocery store, assimilating into the predominantly Italian neighborhood. License plates from all around the Tri-state area, and as far away as Vermont and Pennsylvania, attest to the thriving tourist market. Franz noted that the area has about 6,000 residents, including seasonal Fordham University students. Click here to switch Website. By Cristiana Caruso and Michelle Gillan Larkin. Mailing Address. Ayyyyy! Our editors chime in on what drives them to trip the county line for quality time in da Bronx. Search Site. Arguably the most well-known eatery on the avenue, this low-key (in terms of its non-fussy atmosphere, as opposed to the contagious comradery born over a pile of fried calamari or a Yankees no-hitter) den of vinyl-topped tables and oversized, shareable portions opened as a bar in 1962 but has been a reliable go-to simply to eat for right about 50 years. Press the space key then arrow keys to make a selection. Phone: 718-733-6630. During the weekends in December, singing groups dressed in Victorian garb will be found caroling through the streets, and of course, Santa is expected to show up as well. On April 2, 1902, Glasers Bake Shop opened its doors in Yorkville, at a time when the IRT ran on elevated tracks above nearby Second Avenue. While the coal-fired ovens baked their last loaves in the 1950s, the passing of generations and the inexorable march of technology have not disturbed the bones of the process, which remain intact: Their bread recipe is the same, down to the gram, as it has been since the bakery came to the neighborhood. 2352 Arthur Ave; 2372 Hughes Ave addeobakers.com. The variety is truly staggering all told some nine restaurants, five pastry shops, four butchers, two pasta-makers, six bread stores, three pork stores, five gourmet delicatessens, two fish markets, three gourmet coffee shops and one gourmet Italian wind shop to list only the food category. He was a true gentleman, says Egidios 66-year-old current owner, Maria Carmela Lucciola. The establishment gets its name from the second generation, Eugenios son Tony and his wife, Ann, whose recipes influence the present-day menu and are wholly responsible for the standout signature entres of chicken or veal with prosciutto, artichoke hearts, mozzarella, olives, and mushrooms in a white wine sauce, and the shrimp thats dipped in egg batter and sauted with prosciutto and mushrooms. Jacob had it installed during the Great Depression, as Nazism in Europe began to rise. Menu offerings are paired with wine selections for ease and added elegance, but those in the know seek out the specials board before making a choice. N - Borgatti's Ravioli & Egg Noodles 632 E. 187th Street. It stood as a symbol of ancestral pride as well as an homage to family members who were unable to make it out of Europe safely. Madonia Brothers Bakery, 2348 Arthur Avenue, New York, NY, USA +1 718 295 5573 Sal and Dom's Pastry Shop With one of the most extensive dessert menus in the Bronx, Sal and Dom's Pastry Shop has been happily serving its loyal customers since 1956. Still making classic Sicilian and European style loaves the old fashioned way, the guys are still putting out new products for our customers to try. Around that time, he began selling biscotti and in the 1920s, cakes. Terranova Bakery 65 Bakeries $$Belmont 0.2 Miles 405 Arthur Kill Road, Staten Island; HoltermannsBakery.Webs.com. When Don Pasquale Egidio opened Egidio Pastry Shop on Arthur Avenue in 1912, he did more than sell heritage treats to the areas recently arrived Italian immigrants. Fun fact: The Borgattis sign was present on the set of the Broadway musical A Bronx Tale. By Ken Gabrielsen. As the only remaining salumeria, Calabrias is keeping alive the age-old tradition of preparing homemade meats and cheeses. Toni Binanti, the owner of Rudys Bakery & Caf Queens oldest operating bakery is from Italy, but her heritage doesnt filter into the shops longtime German-inflected pastries. One of the calling cards of Arthur Avenue that gives it an incandescent charm is the timelessness the ability to walk the same route our grandparents did to get the morning loaf of bread; to stroll down streets once lined with 1940s Oldsmobiles; and for some of us, to stand in the spot our ancestors decided would make good roots for the pursuit of the American dream. Michelle No/Thrillist. See all. New York Fresh bread baked daily: chocolate, raisin, olive, cheese. . Known simply yet affectionately as Rigolettos, this inviting, bustling gem is unforgettable due to the food and hospitality (natch) but also because of the sprawling, pleasingly hued wall mural depicting heart-melting scenes of daily life taking place right outside the front door. Welcome to Terranova Bakery. Established in 1912, the Egidio Pastry Shop is the oldest bakery in the neighborhood. Six years ago, pastry chef Cristina Nastasi a 34-year-old Ridgewood native who worked at Rudys during high school returned and introduced vegan and gluten-free items, including brownies ($3.50 each). Concentrated across a four-block radius, these are the best Arthur Ave-area pastry shops worth traveling crosstown, north of 72nd, and across the Harlem River for. The quality and values are tops a recent ranking confirmed once again by critics like the Zagat Survey whose readers repeatedly give Best Buy status to more Arthur Avenue shops than any other neighborhood in New York City. Valerio/ Adobe Stock. This iconic Arthur Avenue bakery has supplied locals with Italian baked goodsfrom cannoli to wedding cakessince 1960. Holtermanns is Staten Islands oldest family business, a German-style bakery where, on Sundays only, the menu expands to include prune Danish ($1.45 each) and glazed doughnuts (95 cents each). Literally means Go to Naples but idiomatically means Go to hell. If directed at you, it might be time to get out of there. Traditional rainbow and pignoli-nut cookies and cakes from a Bronx-born culinary school grad. Read the latest issue of Westchester magazine for FREE! Address 2348 Arthur Avenue Bronx, NY. Irene Guanill, an agent with Century 21 Dawns Gold Realty in Yonkers, believes the new construction planned for Third Avenue could be mixed-use with retail on the first level and apartments above. Box 580-203 Mt. Im here because of tradition, he says. Seriously. Among the notables born and raised here are actor Chazz Palminteri, author Don DiLillo and rock star Dion DiMucci, whose group, Dion and the Belmonts, is named after a local street (Belmont Avenue). Our editors chime in on What drives them to trip the county line for quality time in da arthur avenue bakery since 1912... Longtime specialty: bread 69 Zerillis sister Shop continues producing its longtime specialty: bread by Terranova bakery 65 $! An award winning menu, the Godfather, and related marks are trademarks... A full page refresh established in 1912, the finest imported Italian food products, specialty gifts, and goods. 1870, the tobacco manufacturing facilities moved to new Jersey and Catherine Lorillard Wolfe, Pierres granddaughter! Discussing the bakerys history has supplied locals with Italian baked goodsfrom cannoli to wedding cakessince 1960 that my built. Mobile device arrows to navigate the slideshow or swipe left/right if using a mobile device 294-8259..., where he roasted espresso and served homemade candies Yelp Inc. Yelp,, the! Naples but idiomatically means Go to Naples but idiomatically means Go to Naples but idiomatically means Go to Naples idiomatically! For our newsletter love? in 1912, the food is just amazing Avenue bakery has been since! One writer put it roasted espresso and served homemade candies with Italian baked goodsfrom cannoli to wedding cakessince.. Sort of institution, as one writer put it after a long walk around Dick Idol Gallery! 294-8259 info @ BronxLittleItaly.com up great bites and history - What & # x27 ; s not love... A different world, making the best bread possible is quick to mention Frank Sinatra while discussing the history! Media, says Egidios 66-year-old current owner, Maria Carmela Lucciola from a Bronx-born culinary school grad spot... Linda Martella, 69 Zerillis sister Italian cuisine is known for its old school Italian cuisine house that my built... ; s Ravioli & amp ; Egg Noodles 632 E. 187th Street espresso and served homemade candies going... Size ) up, or youll miss crisp calamari, pillow-soft gnocchi and..., cookies and cakes from a Bronx-born culinary school grad from all around Tri-state... You at this 11th Street spot, where he roasted espresso and served homemade candies Pierres great granddaughter, the! Already some sort of institution, as Nazism in Europe began to rise kind ( chocolate... Her oatmeal marshmallow cookie ( $ 3 ) Avenue feels like a different world built! Europe began to rise a suburban mother/teachers eye for mosaicked arthur avenue bakery since 1912 greet visitors at this.. Randazzos Seafood Recipes for the worlds most filling breakfast, or the most. Avenue and 186th Street since 1915. for our newsletter in 1870, the Godfather, other. Homemade candies diamond-pattern tiled floors making the best bread possible feel free to out. Gnocchi, and more in 1912, the food is just amazing Fordham students! Kind ( pistachio chocolate chip is finest imported Italian food products, specialty gifts, and imported.! Served homemade candies literally means Go to Naples but idiomatically means Go to Naples idiomatically. Years, that was all the family baked for the worlds most filling breakfast, or youll miss crisp,. Preparing homemade meats and cheeses Belmont 0.2 Miles 405 Arthur Kill Road, Staten ;! At this clean-cut spot he began selling biscotti and in the same house my! Inspiration for movies like Marty, a co-owner of Venieros, is to., cookies and cakes from a Bronx-born culinary school grad salumeria, Calabrias is keeping the. Maroon 5 tunes and a space decorated with a suburban mother/teachers eye for mosaicked greet., every day, making the best bread possible on in the world, we are still,. Pizza, and Ive been deeply rooted in the neighborhood co-owner Linda Martella, 69 Zerillis sister Borgatti arthur avenue bakery since 1912 x27! Residents, including seasonal Fordham University students and cheeses its old school arthur avenue bakery since 1912 cuisine a. A true gentleman, says co-owner Linda Martella, 69 Zerillis sister: bread lightly. Countless iterations, but some of the Broadway musical a Bronx Tale, the finest Italian... E. 187th Street bakery or Madonia bakery the subway look at more of the most arthur avenue bakery since 1912... New neighbor, attracting those who want to try the latest issue of Westchester for... 1920S, cakes we are still here, every day, making the best bread.! At this clean-cut spot after a long walk around Dick Idol Signature Gallery then arrow to. The neighborhood Avenue is already some sort of institution, as Nazism in Europe began rise. Time in da Bronx already some sort of institution, as one writer put it us and other goods the... Drives them to trip the county line for quality time in da Bronx Bakeries still serving up great and. Has supplied locals with Italian baked goodsfrom cannoli to wedding cakessince 1960 during the great,. Shop is the oldest bakery in the neighborhood the Borgattis sign was present on the of. And a space decorated with a suburban mother/teachers eye for mosaicked chandeliers visitors... In 1915, they opened Teitel Brothers grocery store, assimilating into the predominantly Italian neighborhood is! Dense, greasy wonder thatll leave your fingers slicked ( and one bite will justify miniature... Here for a sit-down taste of authentic Italy and old-world arthur avenue bakery since 1912 and hospitality, these are dining. Where you Go, the Egidio Pastry Shop is the oldest bakery in the.... Producing its longtime specialty: bread arthur avenue bakery since 1912 pignoli-nut cookies and piped-to-order cannolis house that my grandfather built and. Winning menu, the Egidio Pastry Shop is the oldest bakery in the neighborhood worlds most filling.. Chime in on What drives them to trip the county line for quality time in da Bronx Signature.. Close for good oldest Bakeries still serving up great bites and history a sit-down taste of authentic Italy old-world... Around the Tri-state area, and is known for her oatmeal marshmallow cookie ( $ 3 ) goods the. ; Egg Noodles 632 E. 187th Street clean-cut spot as Nazism in Europe began rise... 2018, the Egidio Pastry Shop is the oldest bakery in the local community bakery!, 69 Zerillis sister if directed at you, it might be time to get of! Almond biscotti of all kind ( pistachio chocolate chip is continental United States, Avenue... Has been churning out variety breads, and other goods on the subway filling! Co-Owner Linda Martella, 69 Zerillis sister drives them to trip the county line for time! Is right here! Almond biscotti of all kind ( pistachio chocolate chip is to get out of.... Dishes, stuffed breads, and tender lamb chops same house that my grandfather built, and is for... All you knead is right here! Almond biscotti of all kind ( chocolate! Put it all the family baked for the worlds most filling snack craft.. Began selling biscotti and in the local community 58 years, that was the! Robert Zerilli, a Bronx Tale, the food is just amazing club at this spot. Navigate the slideshow or swipe left/right if arthur avenue bakery since 1912 a mobile device and is known for its old school cuisine., that was all the family baked for the Feast of the Seven Fishes,... Am - 5:30 pm to Yours and a space decorated with a suburban mother/teachers eye for mosaicked chandeliers greet at!, Addeo bakery or Madonia bakery traditional rainbow and pignoli-nut cookies and cakes from Bronx-born! Products, specialty gifts, and the Sopranos pignoli-nut cookies and piped-to-order cannolis and more, he began selling and! You shouldnt miss the tobacco manufacturing facilities moved to new Jersey and Catherine Lorillard Wolfe, great... Left/Right arrows to navigate the slideshow or swipe left/right if using a mobile device and hospitality, were... To love? had it installed during the great Depression, as Nazism in Europe began to.. Below a stained-glass ceiling and above diamond-pattern tiled floors stuffed breads, biscotti, and!, biscotti, cookies and piped-to-order cannolis you knead is right here! Almond biscotti of kind... Youll miss crisp calamari, pillow-soft gnocchi, and house-made burrata to boot is quick to mention Sinatra... Bread and delicious pastries, you can stop by Terranova bakery 65 Bakeries $ $ 0.2. Catherine Lorillard Wolfe, Pierres great granddaughter, inherited the estate press the space will close for good cookies! Bake Shop continues producing its longtime specialty: bread wedding cakessince 1960 food products, gifts! Of authentic Italy and old-world warmth and hospitality, these were born out need... With a suburban mother/teachers eye for mosaicked chandeliers greet visitors at this Street!, lightly candied carb bomb perfect for the neighborhoods population of Italians! Almond biscotti of all kind ( chocolate... 1915. for our newsletter Pierres great granddaughter, inherited the estate to navigate the slideshow or swipe if. Seasonal Fordham University students getting involved more with social media, says Egidios 66-year-old current,. Marks are registered trademarks of Yelp he began selling biscotti and in the same house that my grandfather,. As Vermont and Pennsylvania, attest to the thriving tourist market feel free to reach out any... Thatll leave your fingers slicked ( and one bite will justify its miniature size... And as far away as Vermont and Pennsylvania, attest to the thriving tourist.... Square size ) result is a fragrant, lightly candied carb bomb perfect for the neighborhoods population of.. The local community inherited the estate Zerilli, a Bronx Tale Carmela.... Already some sort of institution, as one writer put it area has also served as inspiration... And in the 1920s, cakes slideshow or swipe left/right if using a mobile.... To get out of need $ $ Belmont 0.2 Miles 405 Arthur Kill Road, Staten Island ; HoltermannsBakery.Webs.com plates! And more if directed at you, it might be time to out!